Skip to content
Editorial ranking · BMW

CS and CSL: five we would put in the garage

By TUNERS Staff · 5 picks ·

M4 CSL, M2 CS, M3 CS and the special editions with a distinct point of view.

How we ranked them

An editorial order based on how clearly each version expresses its purpose. Exclusivity and horsepower alone do not determine the result; these are factory configurations, not tuned comparisons.

The order reflects TUNERS’ editorial judgment. Sources below support model facts and development history; they do not endorse the ranking.

  1. Number 1: BMW M4 CSL (G82)

    The clearest statement of intent

    The two-seat, rear-drive CSL takes first because its compromises are part of its identity. The carbon details and reduced-weight brief feel like one complete idea, making it our reference for a focused modern M special.

  2. Number 2: BMW M2 CS (G87)

    The newest compact CS chapter

    The G87 CS brings an automatic-only, rear-drive configuration to a body with serious visual weight. We like its place between compact coupe and factory statement car; it should not be confused with the manual-capable F87 CS.

  3. Number 3: BMW M3 CS (G80, 2024 US model)

    Four doors, CS intent

    This M3 CS combines an automatic transmission and M xDrive with the four-door body. It ranks highly because the special-edition treatment still leaves a recognizable sedan, rather than sacrificing the M3 silhouette to make its point.

  4. Number 4: BMW M4 CS (G82)

    The more versatile special coupe

    Four seats and M xDrive distinguish the CS from the CSL. We place it here for anyone attracted to the special-edition detail but who wants a broader-use coupe, with the transmission and traction choices made at the factory.

  5. Number 5: BMW M2 CS (F87)

    The compact original

    The earlier M2 CS earns its place through compact proportions and the availability of a manual gearbox. Its appeal is a different interpretation of CS, not an attempt to beat the G87 on a specification sheet.